Best Pizza in Sayreville NJ

Best Pizza in Sayreville NJ

With a restaurant at the Gateway Shopping Center next to Route 9, Mike’s Pizza is easy to reach for anyone looking for the best pizza in Sayreville NJ. We are known for our classic Neapolitan pizzas prepared by hand-tossing. Our square Sicilian pizzas are also very popular in the community.

Order Now

More Than Just Pizza Place

Despite the name, you can also find burgers, sandwiches, salads, wraps and appetizers at our Italian restaurant in Sayreville NJ. We serve a variety of pasta dishes from the classic creamy Penne Alfredo to the mouthwatering Penne Vodka. Our chicken Caesar wrap is a hot favorite amongst our customers.

Delicious Meals Made With Quality Ingredients

As one of the best pizza places in Sayreville, we source fresh ingredients from trusted producers to prepare and serve you delicious, nutritious meals. Our pizzas come slathered in our special sauce prepared with vine-ripened San Marzano tomatoes and secret ingredients. We prepare and serve each meal warm and fresh so that you can savor it to its fullest.

A Slice As Per Your Taste

What makes us one of the best restaurants in Sayreville NJ is our willingness to accommodate our dishes based on your tastes. Our menu includes vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free dishes as well to help you find something that suits your dietary preference. We also customize items on request to prepare them the way you like it.

Offering Contactless Delivery & Curbside Pickup

We offer contactless delivery and curbside pickup on request as well. You can request them when placing orders. When ordering contactless delivery, leave instructions on where to leave your order and whether to call or text you. Avail of them to stay safe when ordering pizza in Sayreville NJ.


You can find us next to Modell’s Sporting Goods in the Gateway Shopping Center off of Route 9 and Ernston Road. Feel free to visit us whenever you crave some fresh pizza near Main Street, Sayreville NJ.

Get In Touch

For more information on our menu items, restaurant timings, catering services or anything else, contact us now at 732-333-8888 (Sayreville, NJ) or email us at

Order Online